“So Ted, what’s it like fucking my big sister?” Polly asked suddenly. I nearly slammed my head into the fucking metal lid! I was shocked by t...he question and turned-on at the same time, but I acted cool and answered her.“It’s fabulous, a real blast,” I replied. “She’s way, way better than my ex and she’s always so horny! I have to work to keep up!” We talked about Sherry for a couple of minutes and her sister offered me some insight into her personality. She already knew about my wife’s. We shook hands, and I waited for him to reveal that he was my Santa.They asked me to guess, and I named him. I pointed out the things that he had done to give away the secret. He was laughing the whole time. When I finished, he simply said, "Nope."It turned out that my Santa was one of the freshman girls. I was surprised that she had even signed up, because she was supposedly dating a senior. While everybody else laughed at how well they had tricked me, she gave me a shy and embarrassed look. I. I could see her pussy was wet and my mouth started too water. My cock was so hardit was starting to hurt. I had a good view, as they were laying across the bed. Kim would lift her head every few minutes and I could see her tongue lash out a whip across my wifes clit. Catrina was moaning louder and I thought she was about to say she was coming when I heard her say " Joe. I Know you've been watching for a while now,get your ass and big cock in here" I coulnd't believe it, she knew I was there. I. I met her on Craigslist also around August of 2014. A while prior to this era, I made a post on CL just for kicks. The ad was polar opposite of what typical guys would post on there: I'm the guy of you dreams and pussy-panhandling bullshit! I didn't do that. I was straight up and to the point about what I wanted and expected. Surprisingly, I got a plethora of replies--somewhere in the 20s. Most of them were older women. Chell came along when I decided to give up dating all together. She hit me.